FLORIDA MOM FOUND NOT GUILTY BY INSANITY IN TODDLER’S DEATH

FLORIDA MOM FOUND NOT GUILTY BY INSANITY IN TODDLER’S DEATH

A Miami judge found Precious Bland not guilty by reason of insanity on June 23, 2026, for allegedly drowning her 15-month-old daughter in a bathtub and stabbing her husband and teenage daughter in August 2021. Her lawyer’s COVID insanity defense argued that a COVID-induced psychotic episode had convinced her the family needed to be baptized.

Miami-Dade Circuit Judge Miguel de la O made the ruling in a bench trial after Bland waived her right to a jury. He acquitted her on aggravated manslaughter and two counts of attempted first-degree murder.

The alleged attack happened on the night of August 23, 2021, at a home near Northwest 99th Street and 30th Avenue in West Little River. According to the arrest report, as NBC 6 South Florida reported, Bland grew increasingly distressed and told her family, “Jesus Christ is coming and COVID is going to kill us all.”

Investigators said she insisted everyone needed to be baptized and that she would do it in the bathtub. Shortly afterward, the report says, she held her 15-month-old daughter underwater until the child was unresponsive.

Her husband tried to step in, and a struggle followed. Investigators said Bland grabbed a knife and stabbed him multiple times.

He got out with four of the couple’s children, but Bland stabbed her 16-year-old daughter in the forearm before the teen could leave, the report said. Officers found the toddler unresponsive in the tub. She was taken to Jackson North Medical Center and pronounced dead. The husband and teenage daughter were treated at a hospital and released.

Prosecutors called the psychosis a fabrication

Defense attorney Larry Handfield argued that Bland suffered a psychotic episode triggered by COVID-19. He told NBC 6 she had command hallucinations, with voices telling her to baptize family members who were also infected.

Prosecutors rejected that. “The voices and the COVID psychosis are a fabrication and an embellished story,” State Prosecutor Elizabeth Utset said at trial, CBS Miami reported. They argued Bland may have had mental-health issues but understood what she was doing. “COVID is not the issue in this case,” Utset said.

The judge ruled that Bland did not understand the nature or consequences of her actions when she killed her daughter. “There is zero credible explanation other than her psychotic state,” de la O said, according to the Tampa Bay Times.

Handfield described her condition as temporary insanity. He said he believed it was the first successful COVID-related insanity defense in the country.

Backlash and a treatment fight

No sentence was imposed. The Miami Herald reported that Bland had been on house arrest with a GPS monitor since September 2025, after receiving a $10,000 bond. Florida law lets a person found not guilty by reason of insanity be placed on conditional release with a treatment plan and periodic monitoring.

Bland later said in an interview with NBC 6 that she was rebuilding her life, receiving therapy and treatment through the Department of Veterans Affairs, and did not believe she needed hospitalization. “It was something I suffered from, and as a mother, that’s something I have to walk with for the rest of my life,” she said.

Handfield told the station, “It’s a woman who served our country for five years… living the American dream until COVID came. She didn’t ask for COVID. This was COVID.”

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier criticized the ruling. “In a bench trial — where the judge made the decision, not a jury — he allowed a woman off on an insanity defense after she drowned her baby. This is unacceptable,” he said.

Fox News reported that Uthmeier and local lawmakers sought the judge’s impeachment. The Miami Herald noted that only the Legislature can remove a judge, and that Handfield said the judge followed the law and that people reacting without following the trial were jumping to conclusions. Fox also reported that the court appointed forensic psychologist Dayra Bodan to assess whether Bland’s condition warranted involuntary hospitalization.

On July 10, 2026, the judge ruled that Bland would not be institutionalized, CBS Miami reported on July 15, 2026. Instead, she must live with her sister, continue individual psychotherapy and psychiatric follow-up through the VA mental-health system, take prescribed medication, and avoid alcohol and illicit substances. The Mental Health Administrator’s Office monitors the plan.

CBS Miami reported that three mental-health experts testified that the psychotic episode was a rare, one-time occurrence linked to COVID-19.

MORE STORIES