SNIFFING A MALE SWEAT CHEMICAL KEPT WOMEN’S CORTISOL UP
A study published in the Journal of Neuroscience on February 7, 2007, found that 21 heterosexual women who sniffed a male sweat compound called androstadienone kept higher levels of the hormone cortisol than when they sniffed a control substance. The researchers said the compound is found in male sweat, saliva and semen, and the women did not have to do anything but breathe it in.
“We found that merely smelling androstadienone maintained significantly higher levels of the hormone cortisol in women,” the study authors wrote in the abstract.
The paper, titled “Smelling a Single Component of Male Sweat Alters Levels of Cortisol in Women,” came from Claire Wyart, Wallace W. Webster, Jonathan H. Chen, Sarah R. Wilson, Andrew McClary, Rehan M. Khan and Noam Sobel. They chose to measure cortisol because it is linked to arousal and mood.
Each woman came in twice. One day she smelled androstadienone, and on the other she smelled baking yeast, which was picked because its smell was a close match in intensity and pleasantness and because it is not found in sweat. Participants took 20 sniffs of each substance.
The test was double-blind, so neither the women nor the experimenters knew which substance was in play. Sessions ran one week apart at the same time of day, in an odor-controlled room with temperature and humidity control, HEPA and carbon filtration, and stainless-steel-coated surfaces.
The women reported good general health and no chronic medication. None had a history of anosmia or nasal injury, and none used oral contraceptives.
Cortisol levels, measured in saliva, were similar in both conditions at baseline. After exposure, they were significantly higher in the androstadienone condition.
Cortisol generally dropped as the sessions went on, but it fell less after androstadienone. The authors said the effect showed up within 15 minutes and lasted as long as 60 minutes.
The women also gave higher positive-mood ratings and reported more subjective sexual arousal after androstadienone than after the control. A composite autonomic-arousal score was higher too.
What the authors would not claim
The researchers were careful about cause and effect. “We cannot unequivocally determine whether AND influenced cortisol, which then influenced mood, or in turn, whether AND influenced mood through some nonhormonal mechanism, and the change in mood then led to a change in cortisol,” they wrote in the paper, which is available through PubMed Central.
They also did not declare androstadienone a proven human pheromone. They called it a putative chemosignal and described human pheromones as an open scientific question.
The study found one sweat component that can affect cortisol, and the authors noted that it does not establish this is the only sweat ingredient capable of influencing endocrine responses.
The work built on earlier research that reported menstrual-cycle changes after exposure to human sweat. Other earlier work found changes in women’s luteinizing-hormone secretion and mood after exposure to male underarm extracts. Those studies never pinned down the specific molecules responsible.
The team also looked ahead. “We suggest that human chemosignals present a novel and more natural mechanism of endocrine therapy,” they wrote in the discussion section. That was a proposal, not a result, and the study did not demonstrate any treatment or clinical benefit.
A different result under stress
The story did not stay tidy. A 2016 fMRI study tested androstadienone on 31 naturally cycling women in a psychosocial-stress experiment, with 15 in an early-follicular group and 16 in a mid-luteal group.
Its researchers had expected higher cortisol. Instead, they reported that cortisol levels were “surprisingly lower” in all of the women during androstadienone exposure, a result that suggests the hormone’s response may depend on the setting.
