MAN MAILED PEANUT BUTTER CARD TO ALLERGIC WOMAN, COPS SAY

MAN MAILED PEANUT BUTTER CARD TO ALLERGIC WOMAN, COPS SAY

A 68-year-old Florida man allegedly blamed his ex-wife’s best friend for his contentious divorce, so he allegedly mailed her a peanut butter greeting card. Joseph Gerard Cancellare knew the woman had a severe, life-threatening peanut allergy and intentionally exposed her to the allergen, police said.

The incident happened on August 14, 2025. The woman returned home from work and found a blue envelope sitting in her driveway, according to CBS Miami.

Man Mailed Peanut Butter Greeting Card to Allergic Woman
Photo: Joseph Gerard Cancellare via Broward County Jail

The envelope appeared greasy and featured unfamiliar handwriting. It was directed to her using an address from a previous residence.

Investigators said Cancellare used a fictitious return address and name on the envelope. He allegedly sent the card under the name “Goergina Sawals,” Local 10 reported.

When the woman opened the envelope, she discovered a greeting card with a brown substance spread across the inside. She immediately recognized the substance as peanut butter.

She dropped the envelope, called for help and ran inside her house to wash her hands.

“When [the woman] opened the envelope sent by Joseph, she immediately sprang into action to save her life,” investigators wrote in a probable cause affidavit obtained by Law & Crime.

The woman developed hives on both arms and experienced a tingling sensation that lasted for approximately six hours.

Even touching peanuts or encountering airborne peanut particles could trigger a dangerous reaction for the woman. She told police that exposure could affect her breathing and potentially kill her without immediate medical intervention.

“The experience cause her extreme distress that was still visible when she provided the statement over a year later,” investigators wrote in the affidavit.

Tracing the stamps

Plantation police worked with a U.S. postal inspector to trace two Forever stamps attached to the greasy envelope. They tracked the postage to a self-service kiosk at the Davie Post Office on South University Drive.

Investigators used a 15-digit code printed on the stamps to identify the exact machine and the transaction used to buy them. The stamps were purchased on August 8, 2025, using a Visa card that police said belonged to Cancellare.

The self-service kiosk also photographed the person making the purchase. Investigators alleged that Cancellare drove to a post office in a different city from his home and wore sunglasses inside the building to conceal his identity.

When investigators showed the woman the kiosk photograph, she immediately identified the man as Cancellare. Several other people who knew him personally also identified him from the image, including an acquaintance who had played in a band with him.

Cancellare and the woman had known each other for more than 20 years and socialized together with their spouses.

Police said he was familiar with her severe allergy because she frequently had to take precautions when dining at restaurants or attending social gatherings. Witnesses told investigators that Cancellare had personally observed those precautions and knew the deadly consequences of exposing her to peanuts.

The woman’s peanut allergy was previously documented in a May 2017 police report, and investigators reviewed medical records detailing the seriousness of her condition.

Police said the motive stemmed from tensions surrounding Cancellare’s divorce. He allegedly had made several remarks to friends expressing a desire to harm people connected to the situation.

Detectives concluded that Cancellare deliberately mailed the card knowing it could cause serious injury or death. The investigation continued into 2026 while detectives gathered witness statements and medical records.

On November 13, 2026, Plantation police arrested Cancellare at his home. He was taken to HCA Florida Westside Hospital for medical clearance before being transported to the Broward Sheriff’s Office main jail.

Cancellare was charged with one count of aggravated battery with a deadly weapon and one count of culpable negligence exposing another person to harm. His bond was set at $20,000, and he later posted bond, according to People.

MORE STORIES