EX-CAL POLY STUDENT MUST STAND TRIAL IN ALLEGED DUI CRASH

EX-CAL POLY STUDENT MUST STAND TRIAL IN ALLEGED DUI CRASH

A San Luis Obispo County judge ruled on October 19, 2026 that Ishan Pandhare, a 20-year-old former Cal Poly student, must stand trial on all five counts over the Cal Poly Tesla crash that left two fellow students badly hurt. Prosecutors allege Pandhare was driving drunk on January 8, 2026 when he hit the women as they crossed a street, then drove off, and he has pleaded not guilty.

Judge Rita Federman found there was enough evidence to hold him to answer on every charge, the San Luis Obispo Tribune reported. The ruling is not a verdict. It only means the case goes to trial.

Cal Poly Tesla Crash: Driver Ordered to Stand Trial
Photo: Instagram/@zoeygarchibald

Lilianne Burke and Zoey Archibald, both Cal Poly students, suffered major but non-life-threatening injuries. A third woman was also hit but was not hospitalized, police said. Police arrested Pandhare after the car he had been driving was found crashed several blocks away early the next morning.

A roommate’s text and a police interview

The preliminary hearing was the first time the evidence was laid out publicly. Witness Tiffany Mosqueda testified that she watched the women fly past her after the Tesla struck them. “She was launched into the air,” Mosqueda said, estimating one woman traveled 20 to 30 feet. The car stopped briefly at the end of the street, she said, then kept going.

San Luis Obispo Police Officer Jacob Swartz testified that when he arrived, both women were on the ground with “a significant amount of blood” around their heads and what looked like “obvious head injuries.” He said he helped stabilize one woman’s head while waiting for paramedics. The other was taken to the hospital right away.

John Brawley, a Cal Poly student and Pandhare’s first-year roommate, testified that he saw Pandhare at a party earlier that night. He described him as “visibly drunk” and “slurring his words,” and said he saw him taking shots. Brawley said he had only half a beer himself and texted Pandhare not to drive. That was the last time they spoke.

Cal Poly Tesla Crash: Driver Ordered to Stand Trial
Photo: Instagram/@sigmakappaslo

The court also heard a recording of Pandhare’s police interview the day after the crash. He first told officers he thought he was “driving in the middle of the road, but that’s it,” and said he had not been drinking. “We know you’re lying to us,” an officer told him.

Then his account changed. “I think I did run into somebody,” Pandhare said on the recording. “I didn’t do anything illegal, but I was in the middle of the road. I heard a thud, but when I stopped they were already getting help from other people.” He said he left because “I got scared.”

Deputy District Attorney James Michael Graff-Radford told the court the damage to the Tesla, especially the windshield, was consistent with someone driving fast. “He struck three pedestrians in the middle of the road,” he said. Defense attorney Adrienne Haddad did not address the DUI or hit-and-run counts but challenged the reckless driving charge. “Driving fast in of itself is not evidence of reckless driving,” she said.

The charges and the lawsuit

Prosecutors charged Pandhare on February 2, 2026 with three felonies: DUI, reckless driving causing a specified injury and hit-and-run causing injury. He also faces a misdemeanor hit-and-run count involving property damage and a speeding infraction, plus four sentencing enhancements, three for great bodily injury and one for multiple victims. Mustang News reported that he pleaded not guilty and denied the enhancements at his February 4, 2026 arraignment.

Cal Poly Tesla Crash: Driver Ordered to Stand Trial
Photo: LinkedIn/Zoey Archibald

Burke and Archibald also sued in San Luis Obispo County Superior Court on July 10, 2026. Their complaint, which the New York Post detailed, alleges Pandhare was going about 60 mph in a 25 mph zone and did not brake or try to slow down. It says the women were left “like run over garbage in the roadway.”

The suit also names the Kappa Sigma fraternity and other students. It alleges alcohol was given to an underage Pandhare and that dangerous drinking practices, including hazing, were involved. It further alleges the car’s owner handed him the keys despite knowing, or having reason to know, that he was intoxicated. Those claims are allegations that have not been proven in court.

Archibald’s attorney, Theo Emison, told the Tribune the women were “run over and left bleeding in the road by an underage driver under the influence who cowardly fled the scene.” Burke’s attorney, Christopher Dolan, called the suit “a wake-up call to the alcohol culture in colleges and universities.”

Pandhare was suspended from Cal Poly and posted $150,000 bail, International Business Times UK reported. He has been living with his parents in San Diego, and both he and his parents declined to comment after the hearing. His next court date was set for December 2, 2026.

MORE STORIES